beetiger: (Default)
[personal profile] beetiger
I’m back from a week of pure escapist lounging in Key West. I managed to get plenty of sun without collecting a sunburn, plenty of water while only getting slightly queasy once or twice, several slices of excellent Key Lime pie, the opportunity to commune with both stray cats and chickens and captive butterflies, and my recommended weekly allowance of drag shows. The week’s soundtrack was overall excellent, though [personal profile] lediva did lament the lack of Beach Boys. Most importantly, I got a well-needed big ol’ chunk of high-quality time with [livejournal.com profile] lediva, who is just an amazingly wonderful person to be around.

We stayed at Pearl’s Rainbow, a women-only resort in the old part of Key West, and a perfect home base for wandering around. It was quirky and comfortable and populated by older-than-Spring-Breakers lesbian couples, who lounged around a pool surrounded by tropical plants, sunning themselves. It was cozy and safe feeling and just right. I’m not sure why part of me feels, on a gut level, that these people are more like me than the perfect-in-a-bikini 22 year-old Spring Breakers on the boats, without talking to either of them. It’s all physical stereotyping, and it makes me feel vaguely ashamed when I catch myself at it. Sometimes I feel like a real fake in lesbian spaces, me with the wedding ring and the phallic talisman tucked into my clothing and the sort of straightish look and the determinedly ambisexual spirit.

In general, I’m kind of conflicted about the fact that I really enjoy women’s spaces, gay or straight. I know so many gender-variant people who’d love to be welcomed into that kind of community, and just can’t for physical reasons manage it. I know people in male bodies who are much more safe/caring/loving/add-your-own-stereotype-here than some women that I know. I’ve been in women’s groups where people are gossipy, catty, and just not very nice, and ones where the main topic of conversation is male-bashing. And I can’t really put my finger firmly on what the difference in womanspace is, something that feels energetically different, something about the gender sameness that matters, even though by all reasonable rights it shouldn’t. Nevertheless I really crave it, especially in a spiritual/religious context.

Now I’m back in the office, with a lab bay filled with about seventeen quadrillion boxes that got sent to me during the week, a dusting of snow on the grass outside, and no increase in desire to hang out with my coworkers, whom I’m not sure noticed that I was gone. Life goes on.

Date: 2003-04-01 02:39 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] secanth.livejournal.com
I realize you feel strongly, PV. But in this case...yes, there are reasons. I'm not going into her secrets here, but she has more than enough justification to distrust men. There ARE things you don't know about her...or me. For her...and for me...such fears are not totally irrational. As I said, I was speaking out of knowledge of my relationship. Yes, you should have just as much right as I do to be comfortable...but keep in mind that not all of us CAN be comfortable in the same situations.

Re:

Date: 2003-04-01 05:37 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] queenofstripes.livejournal.com
They ARE irrational, Secanth, because I AM NOT THEM. It is IRRATIONAL to ascribe characteristics which you KNOW somebody does not possess because they happen to belong to other people who share a superficial characteristic with them, however widespread. And again, I still sympathize 100% with her concerns, and do not demand that she or anyone else recover from them on my timetable for my convenience, but I still think it is an utterly misguided and damaging social policy to reinforce those concerns rather than dealing with their root causes. If you can find me one thing that inheres in my Y chromosome or my body in general that makes me a credible threat to do whatever it is that justifies her distrust in men, I invite you to tell me what it is. Otherwise, you are calling me something that I am not, and I will not accept that.

Furthermore, I still haven't heard anyone stand up and tell me why, since black people have done things just as heinous to white people as whatever happened to your lover, and vice versa, it is not just as acceptable to create whites-only spaces -- or, for that matter, men-only spaces.

Secanth, you know that a great many of Runnerwolf and my friends from CWRU were abused or traumatized by their parents -- people 30 and over. And despite that, we love a great many people 30 and over. Imagine the coolest science fiction convention in the country, one to which all your friends were going, one at which certain things happened which did not and probably could not happen anywhere else in the world, things which are very close to your heart... Now, imagine that because of a few people who had been traumatized by the actions of older people there, the entire convention decided to bar all people over thirty.

How would that make you feel, Secanth? How would it make you feel to be told that, simply because of something which you can't help and take for granted about yourself, something you'd accepted and had never really had a problem with before, you are unworthy of our company at this convention? Wouldn't it sting just a little? Wouldn't you have to wonder just a bit why lil' ol' you is suddenly this big threat? Can't you imagine that, just for a moment, your self-confidence would be addled and all the stereotypes and fears associated with age would come knocking at the door, that you're too authoritarian, too prudish, too outmoded, just plain too obsolete? And if you failed to fend those fears off, can't you imagine that you might walk around for the rest of your life wondering if, no matter all the nice things your younger friends say about you, if some of these stereotypes aren't true?

Date: 2003-04-01 06:03 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] secanth.livejournal.com
PV, there are some things I will NOT discuss in a public forum. And why do you assume it only happened to FC? Let us just say that some kinds of abuse provoke fears that are NOT rational, and will not go away simply because we wish them to, and MAY not go away after years of therapy. We don't stop fearing simply because someone says "Oh, gee...you know I'M no threat"....espically when it's a line you've heard before from your abuser. No, you are not an abuser, and I am quite aware you are not that kind of person. And I'm sure it hurts to be 'lumped' into the same catagory. It hurts ME when I'm judged to be 'lazy, slovenly, stupid, and no willpower' simply because I'm fat. It hurt when I was in high school and I was considered 'unworthy' of anything but being teased and laughed at and it hurts now. It hurts when someone assumes I'm a stupid hillbilly. It hurts when someone assumes I'm to damn old to understand anything.

But some traumas go far too deep to go away just because we wish them to....some take years of therapy just to LIVE with, much less overcome. And if you happen to be able to turn back time, by all means go back and deal with the root causes...because otherwise you have to deal with the results. Or rather, she and I deal with the results. I'd love to be able to make it all go away, let us both forget it, and move on...but sometimes it doesn't work that way.

Re:

Date: 2003-04-01 06:42 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] queenofstripes.livejournal.com
I didn't expect you would discuss it here, and I know quite well that she's not the only one such things have happened to. I know because I've seen the disgustingly large portion of my female friends who have gone through... well, what I think I have a pretty good guess you're talking about, and we'll leave it at that. I'm sorry if I came off as excessively insistent that she "get over" this -- that was insensitive, but I do still feel that the fact the trauma has registered as an across-the-board suspicion of males, no matter what other characteristics they may have, is utterly wrong and harmful. I blame FC ZERO PERCENT for this and the way our society -- men, super-especially -- have shaped the way we thinking about these things, making it first and foremost a matter of gender instead of a matter of morality. And I feel the feminist community could be doing something to heal this gap between men and women, do something to promote an archetype of masculinity that wasn't juvenile, possessive, controlling, and violent... but instead it just reinforces the idea that this is men's fault and removing the men will remove the problem, no matter how many other problems it causes.

Believe me, the issue of the masculine propensity for abuse and violence weighs pretty heavily on my mind, and it scares the hell of me that I'm even peripherally a part of it. It twists my soul and shatters my internal mirrors. I can't so much as raise my voice to Rik or Runnerwolf during a friendly argument without feeling like every heavy on every Lifetime movie of the week. I've wanted to put a fist through the window every time I've heard one of my female friends recount her suffering. I've seriously pondered taking a train to Canada to strangle the man who assaulted D*****n when she was younger. I've wanted to cut my balls off with a knife when I've second-guessed what that very capacity for indignant rage said about me and my prospects to become a gentle and loving human being, fully accepted by my friends as worthy of emotional intimacy. So yes... you could say I'm a little bit aware of the issue.

Date: 2003-04-01 06:49 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] secanth.livejournal.com
You guess right, my dear, and I didn't mean to come on so strong either. Actually, considering that FC had a 26 year marriage, three lovely daughters, and is a Viking in the SCA and has several dozen male friends...she's done pretty well. It just in SOME areas that there is still a measure of distrust.

(((Hugs))) I remember a certain wall and a certain convention....and a certain conversation we had. (smile) I know it bothers you, believe me.

Date: 2003-04-01 07:03 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] queenofstripes.livejournal.com
You know, I clicked to post a comment to you elsewhere on this thread, and at the very moment that the error message that ate the comment showed up in the browser window... my mp3 of "Me and Dorothy Parker" by the Flash Girls came up on WinAmp. Speaking of masculine violence... I just want to state publically that if I ever get the chance to meet Eris face-to-face, I am going to walk right up to that silly, wicked goddess and bite her right on the shoulder.

Date: 2003-04-01 07:20 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] secanth.livejournal.com
Okay, NOW I have to clean off my monitor screen....

Re:

Date: 2003-04-01 07:21 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] queenofstripes.livejournal.com
The worst part is, she'd probably make me do it again... ^_-

December 2013

S M T W T F S
1234567
89 1011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
293031    

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Mar. 1st, 2026 06:06 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios